Is Africa digitally dominated by surveillance capitalism?

A silent but profound form of dominance is underway, spearheaded not by nations
but by tech behemoths that dominate the digital realm. It pertains to these powerful entities' control and use of data, algorithms, and digital spaces to extend their economic and political dominion.

It is crucial to note that the parallels between this digital age and the era of historic dominance of foreign nations are stark. Much like the scramble for African territories in the past, today, the continent is a battleground for user data, with corporations vying to extract valuable information, often without the individual's explicit consent.

Modern manifestations through data extraction by tech giants:

The depth of this new-age dominance is seen in data extraction. Tech giants develop platforms and algorithms with addictive properties, encouraging users to give away more of their data, which is then harnessed for economic gains.

According to scholars like Shoshana Zuboff, this age is characterised by “surveillance capitalism,” a system where human experience is unethically translated into data, which is then leveraged for profit.

Drawing a clear line between history's past and today’s digital age, we notice a
common element of exploitation. The economic disparity fostered through the
historic domination of foreign powers is mirrored in the digital space. Today, African countries provide raw data, akin to raw materials, which are processed and monetized elsewhere, rarely returning derived economic benefits back to the
continent, at least not in fair proportion.

The role of data in modern business:

The adage “data is the new oil” has recently gained prominence, underscoring data’s centrality in driving modern business landscapes. Corporations leverage vast amounts of data to gain insights, streamline operations, and foster innovation.

Harvard Business Review notes that data-driven organizations are 23 times more
likely to acquire customers, six times as likely to retain customers, and 19 times as likely to be profitable as a result.

The vast amount of data harvested from digital platforms allows businesses to tailor products and services to individual preferences, radically altering the landscape of trade and commerce. Additionally, McKinsey Global Institute asserts that data-driven strategies can unlock economic benefits, including increasing profitability by 60% for retail companies.

The African Landscape:

Turning our lens towards the African continent, we find a region buzzing with digital potential yet contending with a mosaic of policy landscapes on data protection and cyber security. As per the UN Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD), while African nations have been making strides in developing digital economies, 66% of countries still lack data protection and privacy laws.

African nations are at a pivotal juncture where the right policy frameworks can
catalyze a burgeoning digital economy. However, this path is fraught with
challenges, including infrastructure deficits and a digital divide that threatens to leave many behind.

South Africa: As a frontrunner, South Africa’s Protection of Personal
Information Act (POPIA) represents a comprehensive approach to data protection,
positioning the nation as a leader in safeguarding user data in the digital space.

Nigeria: In Nigeria, the National Information Technology Development Agency (NITDA) established guidelines for data protection. Despite this, experts argue that enforcement remains a substantial challenge, with corporations largely self-regulating, resulting in potential conflicts of interest.

Ghana: The Data Protection Act of 2012 in Ghana stands as an early move in West Africa to establish a legal framework for data protection. Yet, there remains room for bolstering enforcement mechanisms and fostering broader public
awareness regarding data rights.

Limits of data protection laws:

As we venture deeper into the intricacies of digital colonialism, it becomes key to trace the existing loopholes in the data protection laws that render them less effective. According to a report by the Global Privacy Assembly, many African nations struggle with enforcement mechanisms, illustrating a gap between policy formulation and its actual implementation.

An instance of data privacy violations:

Historically, we've witnessed significant breaches that highlight these loopholes vividly. For instance, the South African company, Liberty Holdings, suffered a cyber-attack a few years back, resulting in a considerable data breach. These incidents signify the vulnerabilities entrenched in the digital sphere and point to a pressing need for robust protective frameworks.

Though designed to act as deterrents, sanctions often fall short in the dynamic digital landscape. An article published in the Journal of International Affairs points out that sanctions often fail to prevent exploitation fully, given the rapid advancements and the evolving nature of technology.

Market domination:

Venturing into the sphere of market dynamics, we find large tech companies
assuming almost monopolistic positions, controlling vast swathes of data. This
market concentration can diminish competition, stifle innovation, and result in
economic imbalances, a scenario frighteningly reminiscent of history past where a select few controlled the resources.

The role of competition enforcement in safeguarding interests:

To counteract this dominance, competition enforcement emerges as a vital tool.
Experts suggest that fostering a competitive environment could act as a check on the monopolistic tendencies of these behemoth tech companies, thereby safeguarding broader interests. The African Competition Forum (ACF) has been pivotal in promoting a culture of competition by encouraging national competition policies and creating awareness among stakeholders.

Social, political, and economic implications:

Digital dominance carries deep-seated repercussions reverberating through African society's social, political, and economic fibres.

On the social front, there is a palpable increase in the digital divide. Politically, data has become a tool for manipulation and misinformation. The Cambridge Analytica scandal is a stark reminder of how data harvested can be used to manipulate voters in various African countries, underscoring a pressing need for stringent data governance frameworks.

Economically, the essence of digital dominance pivots on data exploitation - deemed as the "new oil". This exploitation results in economic disparities, with African countries losing out on the monetary benefits that should ideally accrue from the judicious use of their data.

Forward outlook from the past:

As we cast our gaze back to the Berlin Conference, a seminal moment which
orchestrated an unprecedented scramble for Africa, we find the roots of a persistent battle against external dominance – a struggle that has metamorphosed into the modern-day ordeal facing digital supremacy in Africa.

Much like its predecessor, this form of hegemony is carving out a new landscape of control, now conquering through data and digital platforms and thus unveiling the stark reality of digital dominance. This reality is not relegated to theoretical discourses; what I speak of dynamically influences socioeconomic and political landscapes. I advocate for a difference in playmakers substantiated by facts rather than mere speculative theories.

Stepping carefully into an era punctuated with both promises and uncertainties, African nations must champion the creation of secure digital infrastructures. Drawing inspiration from well-structured frameworks such as the European Union's General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), there is a mounting necessity for stringent data protection laws that serve as fortresses against exploitation.

Noteworthy in this discourse is the insightful analysis offered by Shoshana Zuboff in "The Age of Surveillance Capitalism", a work that underscores the pressing need to regain autonomy over the digital sphere, a move intrinsically linked to safeguarding the digital rights and dignities of the African citizenry.

Vision for the future:

As we project our sights towards the future, the ambition is to foster a continent that stands independent and resilient, far removed from the hold of external digital dominance, nurturing a harmonious digital ecosystem anchored in principles of equity and inclusivity. The roadmap to this future mandates African countries to cultivate and promote homegrown technological innovations diligently, thereby steering towards self-sufficiency and enhancing the intrinsic digital economy.

The criticism is not leveraged at foreign investments but squarely at the underutilization of local funds towards the growth of local talent: the underutilization of local funds which should be actively channeled to foster local stakeholder gains by local stakeholders.

It's not like I don't see Bentleys on the roads of Accra. I humbly suggest a collaborative and multi-faceted strategy where governments, tech industry giants, civil societies, and indigenous investors come together to weave a
tapestry of digital sovereignty, hence forging a pathway to an empowered Africa, by Africa, for Africa.

This partnership promises growth and a sustainable development trajectory that
accommodates the varied stakeholders in the digital space. With a clear vision backed by foresighted strategies, there lies a promising horizon for Africa, where the digital future is a vivid reflection of its diverse and rich cultural
heritage.

It speaks of a renaissance, a resurgence governed not by external forces
but masterfully orchestrated by Africa for its people, providing a canvas for an
authentically African narrative. It is a bold stance against external digital dominance, forging a future rooted deeply in the principles of self-sufficiency, autonomy, and respect for the rich tapestry of African heritage, envisaging an era of unprecedented digital empowerment for the continent.