Finance Ministry warns of potential $3.8 billion loss over anti-LGBTQ bill

Ghanaian

The Ministry of Finance is urging President Akufo-Addo to refrain from assenting to the recently passed anti-LGBTQ bill, citing potential severe financial consequences for Ghana.

In a press release on March 4, 2024, the Finance Ministry cautioned that approving the bill could lead to a substantial loss of World Bank financing, estimating a potential USD$3.8 billion loss over the next

Read full articlefive to six years.

Specifically, the projected impact for 2024 includes a loss of USD$600 million in budget support and USD$250 million for the Financial Stability Fund, potentially affecting Ghana's foreign exchange reserves and exchange rate stability.

In response to these potential financial setbacks, the Finance Ministry recommends that the President engage with religious bodies to discuss the economic implications of signing the bill. They also suggest establishing a robust coalition and framework for supporting key development initiatives that may be adversely affected.

The Finance Ministry's statement proposes, "The Presidency may have a structured engagement with local conservative forces such as religious bodies and faith-based organisations to communicate the economic implications of the passage of the 'Anti-LGBTQ' Bill and to build a stronger coalition and a framework for supporting key development initiatives that are likely to be affected."

Additionally, the Finance Ministry suggests that the President may need to defer assenting to the bill until the court rules on the legal issues raised by key national stakeholders, including civil society organizations (CSOs) and the Commission on Human Rights and Administrative Justice (CHRAJ). The statement highlights the potential economic impact and the importance of careful consideration before finalizing the decision on the controversial legislation.

Below is the statement from the Ministry of Finance:

Impact on World Bank-funded programmes

i. The expected US$300 million financing from the First Ghana Resilient Recovery Development Policy Operation (Budget Support) which is currently pending Parliamentary approval might not be disbursed by the Bank when it is approved by Parliament.;

ii. On-going negotiations on the Second Ghana Resilient Recovery Development Policy Operation (Budget Support) amounting to US$300 million may be suspended;

iii. On-going negotiations for US$250 million to support the Ghana Financial Stability Fund may be suspended;

iv. Disbursement of undisbursed amounts totaling US$2.1 billion for on-going projects will be suspended; and

v. Preparation of pipeline projects and declaration of effectiveness for two projects totaling worth US$900million may be suspended. Full details of the World Bank portfolio are attached as Appendix 1 & 2.

vi. In total, Ghana is likely to lose US$3.8 billion in World Bank Financing over the next five to six years. For 2024 Ghana will lose US$600 million Budget support and US$250 million for the Financial Stability Fund. This will negatively impact on Ghana’s foreign exchange reserves and exchange rate stability as these inflows are expected to shore the country’s reserve position.

Impact on the Implementation of the 2024 Budget

The potential loss of these financial resources creates a financing gap in the 2024 budget that must be addressed either through a significant reduction in the expenditures or additional domestic revenue mobilisation. Failing this, Government’s ability to achieve the targets in the 2024 Budget will be undermined and the IMF-ECF Programme will be derailed.

Impact in the IMF Programme

While there is no direct conditionality in the IMF-ECF Programme relating to the passage of the Bill, the principles of the current IMF-ECF Programme are built on predictable financing from Development Partners (Financing Assurances) including the World Bank funded Ghana Resilience Recovery Development Policy Operations. Hence the non-disbursement of the Budget Support from the World Bank will derail the IMF programme. This will in turn trigger a market reaction which will affect the stability of the exchange rate.

Impact on Debt Restructuring Programme

Negotiations with the Official Creditor Committee (OCC) and Eurobond holders under Ghana’s debt restructuring programme is predicated on the success of the IMF programme. Hence, a derailed IMF programme will have dire consequences on the debt restructuring exercise and Ghana’s long term debt sustainability.

Impact on African Development Bank Programmes

The African Development Bank has indicated that the passage of the bill will not have any adverse impact on the cooperation with Ghana.

Possible adverse reaction from Germany and the wider European Community

In several discussions, with officials from the German Government, MoF officials have been informed that the German Government is against the passage of the Bill. Given Germany’s relative strong influence in the European Union and the Official Creditor Committee, there is the need to manage the relationship to forestall a strong negative reaction.

3. RECOMMENDATIONS

i. At the Presidency level, We recommend;

a. a structured engagement with local conservative forces such as religious bodies and faith-based organizations to communicate the economic implications of the passage of the “Anti LGBTQ” Bill and to build a stronger coalition and a framework for supporting key development initiative that are likely to be affected;

b. an effective engagement with conservative countries, including the Arab countries and China. This could help trigger resources to fill in the potential financing gaps to be created; and

c. H.E. the President may have to defer assenting to the Bill until the court rules on the legal issues tabled by key national stakeholders (CSOs and CHRAJ).

ii. At the MOF Level,
a. The Ministry will continue to engage with the IMF on the alternative credible sources of funding that will plug the financing gap;

b. GRA to embark on a vigorous revenue mobilisation drive focusing on implementation of approved measures as well as compliance;

c. Consider possible expenditure rationalisation to accommodate the shock from the potential withdrawal of resources; and

d. Leverage on the Ghana Beyond Aid Principles and change the structure of our resource mobilisation. We must improve our domestic resource mobilisation efforts by working towards our medium-term tax revenue to GDP target of 17%-18% and eventually wean ourselves off the unsustainable dependency on development assistance.

4. CONCLUSIONS

The passage of the new Bill calls for fortifying local financial systems, strengthening African financial institutions as well as our development journey in partnership with other countries. In line with the Ghana Beyond Aid Agenda, Ghana can navigate the complexities of international relations and emerge with a robust, resilient economy with Ghanaian ownership of the commanding heights of the economy.